The Gaming Goat's Magic: the Gathering Buy List

So, you want to sell us some cards?

We are always buying and would more than happy to give you cash or store credit for your cards! Selling your cards is very easy, just follow the directions below:

  1. Download our Buy List *Please note all prices are for near mint condition. See our grading guide for more information.
  2. Send us an email listing the cards (including set, quantity, and condition notes) you are selling and make sure to note how you would like paid (check, Paypal, or store credit).
  3. Mail your cards to:
    The Gaming Goat
    ATTN: Buying Dept.
    1115 N. Salem Dr
    Schaumburg, IL 60194
As you will see, our buy list is pretty extensive; however, you might come across cards that, for one reason or another, aren't on it. If you have questions, please just ask.